Surviving My Son's Terrifying Kindergarten Tales

At a kindergarten family day, a mother overhears her son Caleb Sheridan whisper that a classmate, Bryan Hunter, was dragged to a punishment room for complaining about the cafeteria food. Bryan's mother, Annette Morris, dismisses it, sending a video of Bryan eating happily and insisting his food allergies have vanished thanks to the new teacher, Vera Jones. But Caleb is certain he saw Bryan taken away by a teacher in a hat, crying and pale, and locked behind a black door.

Annette's angry call insists nothing happened, yet the mother cannot forget that Bryan once could not breathe near celery. Her husband Isaac Sheridan, a police officer, suggests Caleb simply mixed up a kidnapping case he was told about with reality.

Still, the doubts refuse to settle, and the questions about what really happens behind the kindergarten's doors only grow.