The Guy I've Had a Crush on for Years Got Together with My Roommate

At their performing arts school, Olivia has quietly carried a crush on Asher for five years. When he returns to the States, she introduces him to her roommate Daphne, the school's famed "straight guy killer." Within days, Daphne announces that she and Asher are together, and Olivia is folded into their dates as a grateful third wheel, watching the boy she loves dote on her roommate.

As Daphne skips classes and misses rehearsals, her instructor, Ms. Harrison, warns that her place in the upcoming competition is at risk. Daphne chooses Asher's birthday over practice, and her competition eligibility is revoked. Olivia, long in her shadow, steps onto the stage in her place.

After Olivia wins first place and a place in the National Dance Company, a small tattoo on Asher's ring finger catches her eye, and the name Daphne gives for it is not the one Olivia remembers.