Chapter 3We Never Got To See Our Dawn Together
About 5,035 characters (~965 words) — this is Chapter 3, one of 4 free chapters on EditWrx Reads.
"Heh. She's got an attitude."
A smile played on his lips.
He looked up, and his eyes met mine.
We both froze.
We looked away at the exact same time.
The silence that followed was suffocating.
Under the blankets, my fingernails were digging so hard into my palms they were practically drawing blood.
Noah broke the silence first.
"Riley."
He never used to call me by my real name.
That single word clarified exactly where we stood.
He cleared his throat. "I'm really sorry about the mix up. I know it caused you a lot of trouble."
"It was a terrible mistake, and I hope you aren't holding it against me."
"Let's just look at it as making a good friend to talk to."
"Yeah?"
A mistake. Terrible. A friend.
An entire year of late night talks, inside jokes, and falling in love, summed up in three pathetic words.
I kept my eyes glued to the blanket.
I nodded once.
I didn't look at him. I didn't speak.
He stood up. "Your IV is done. I'll drive you back."
I wanted to tell him no.
But I looked down at the heavy plaster on my leg.
I pictured myself trying to hop back across campus alone.
I caved.
Noah was strong.
He scooped me up effortlessly and carried me to his car.
Pressed against his chest, my hands hovered awkwardly. I didn't know where to hold on, so I ended up tightly gripping the fabric of my own faded shirt.
He smelled incredible. It was that crisp citrus scent I had once told him was my absolute favorite.
My stupid, traitorous heart hammered against his chest.
His voice rumbled right next to my ear.
The voice that used to live exclusively in my headphones was right here in the physical world.
The only difference was the tone.
In my headphones, he was sweet, needy, and deeply affectionate.
Now, he was just rattling off medical instructions on how to keep the cast dry.
I barely absorbed a word he said. My mind was a complete wreck.
He carried me all the way to my dorm room door.
He didn't step inside.
But he didn't leave either.
Leaning against the doorframe, I quietly said, "Thank you for the ride."
He pulled out his phone to check the time. "No problem. It was on the way."
My heart sank straight to the bottom of the ocean.
I realized he was waiting for Fiona.
And I had been foolish enough to think he went out of his way just to make sure I got home safe.
I turned around and limped into the room.
It took everything in me to climb up into my bed.
My hand slipped, and my knuckles slammed hard against the bed frame. The sharp sting brought fresh tears to my eyes.
Right then, Fiona's surprised voice echoed from the hallway.
"Noah! What are you doing here?"
"Waiting for you." Noah's voice was warm, dripping with that familiar smile. "Be my girlfriend? I'll wait for you every day."
Pure instinct made me slap both hands over my ears.
But I still heard her answer.
"I'd love that, boyfriend."
The hot pre-med student officially bagged the beautiful dancer.
The news blew up across every campus group chat.
I took a week off to recover in my dorm.
Even though I didn't step outside, I couldn't escape the endless updates about Fiona and Noah.
Someone posted a picture of Fiona practicing in the studio, with Noah leaning casually against the doorframe, watching her with a soft smile.
Another showed Noah dominating a soccer game, while Fiona sat in the bleachers holding his water bottle.
There were candids of them holding hands, strolling side by side under the campus oak trees.
...
These were all the things Noah had promised me.
He had told me that as soon as we met in person, the first thing he wanted was to watch me dance.
He wanted me to cheer for him at his games.
He wanted to hold my hand and walk around campus.
I was the one he dated for a year.
But she was the one living out our promises.
And I was the one left completely broken.
I stared at his contact, still pinned to the very top of my messages.
The icon that used to pop up with a good morning text every single day.
I pressed down on it, hovering over the delete button.
I thought about the thousands of messages we shared over the last year.
I couldn't do it.
I just unpinned him.
Once he was unpinned, his name sank further and further down my inbox.
It was only then I realized that the guy who used to tell me goodnight every single evening hadn't sent me a single word in almost a week.
When it was time to get my cast off, I saw Noah at the clinic again.
His buddy was giving him a hard time.
"Whoa, the guy who's been MIA for a week playing boyfriend actually showed up to the clinic?"
"Did you really come all the way down here just to take a cast off a freshman?"
I was sitting in the examination room, separated from them by a thin curtain.
I heard Noah's voice.
"Do me a favor. When she gets here, tell her she needs to keep it on for a couple more days."
His friend sounded confused. "Why? You're the one who put the cast on her, and you literally said she was cleared to take it off today."
"Just drop it," Noah said flatly. "Make up some excuse. Tell her the bone isn't fully set yet. Make her wait two days."
"The intercollegiate dance competition is the day after tomorrow, and Fiona is competing."