Chapter 3The $380,000 Debt
About 4,759 characters (~866 words) — this is Chapter 3, one of 4 free chapters on EditWrx Reads.
I spent two hours making a new spreadsheet.
Header read:
[Recalculation of Scarlett's Family Accounts]
I listed every sum of money.
Part 1: My Expenditures.
2018-2024 Annual transfers to parents: $185,000
2020 Dad's hospitalization: $15,000
2022 Brother's wedding gift: $10,000
2023 Sister's baby: $5,000
Annual holiday red envelopes: Approx 7 years × $3,000 = $21,000
Subtotal: $236,000
Part 2: Parents' Expenditures for Sister.
Dowry: $200,000
Car: $120,000
Furniture/Appliances: Approx $30,000
Subtotal: $350,000
Part 3: Parents' Expenditures for Brother.
House Down Payment: $350,000
Wedding Gift: $120,000
Renovation Subsidy: $50,000
Subtotal: $520,000
Part 4: Parents' Expenditures for Me.
Given at wedding: $6,000
Wedding money taken away: -$80,000
Actual: -$74,000
David watched beside me, face getting darker.
"So..."
"So by my mom's logic," I pointed at the table, "Sister got $350k, Brother got $520k, I lost $74k."
"But in her bill..."
"In her bill, Sister surplus $120k, Brother surplus $20k, I owe $380k."
David took a few deep breaths.
"How did she calculate?"
"Because she only counts raising costs, not money given out." I smiled. "What she gave Sister and Brother is called 'Parental Love'. What she took from me is called 'You Should'."
David stopped talking.
I saved the screenshot of the table.
"You really going to post in the group?" He asked.
"Not rushing."
"Then what do you want to do?"
I thought about it.
"I won't post first. I'll wait, see what else they say."
David nodded.
"I support you. Whatever you decide, I stand by your side."
My heart warmed a bit.
Luckily, I have him.
Next day, Mom called.
I didn't answer.
Called three more times.
Still didn't answer.
Then WeChat voice call.
Then text message.
Text content:
"Scarlett, are you trying to piss me off? Your dad knows this, his blood pressure went up from anger. Are you still part of this family? Call me back immediately!"
I put phone on silent.
David asked: "You really not answering?"
"Say what if I answer? She opens mouth with 'You owe me $380k'. I answer a hundred calls, she says the same thing."
"Then how long you plan to stay cold?"
"Wait till she calms down."
But my mom didn't plan to calm down.
In the afternoon, Sister sent WeChat.
"Sis, Mom asked me to persuade you. Don't be stubborn with her, she's old, can't stand anger."
"Sis, do you think this bill is reasonable?"
"Reasonable or not, she is your mom."
"So I have to accept?"
"Can't you yield a bit? $380k, you just pay slowly. A few tens of thousands a year, done in ten years."
"Sis, let me ask you, the money you gave Mom, did she ever ask you to pay back?"
Sister didn't reply.
I continued: "You know how much you give her annually. New Year two or three thousand, birthday few hundred, holidays token gesture. Add up these years, is it $50k?"
"That's different!"
"How is it different?"
"Money I give Mom is filial piety. Money you give Mom... is also filial piety. But your raising cost is higher, you went to better college, spent more money than me."
"I got into college myself, half of my college living expenses I earned part-time. Did Mom count these?"
Sister was silent.
"Sis," she changed tone, "We are family, don't calculate so much. Mom is old, she does this for the good of the family."
"For the good of the family? Sis, tell me, in this 'family', is there me?"
"What do you mean?"
"I mean, this bill benefits Sister, benefits Brother, harms me. Who is this 'family' for?"
Sister stopped talking.
I continued typing:
"Sis, you said I wasn't likable since childhood. But do you know why? Because I can't pretend. I can't be like you, saying yes to whatever Mom says. I can't be like Brother, asking for whatever. I just be myself, then got called 'not pleasing'."
"This..."
"I'm not pleasing, so I'm not valuable. I'm not valuable, so I have no dowry. No dowry, still have to pay mortgage for Brother, be ATM for Sister. Now Mom calculated a bill, Sister surplus $120k, Brother surplus $20k, I owe $380k. Sis, do you think this is reasonable?"
Sister's reply came:
"Scarlett, you are too extreme."
I laughed.
"Yes, I am too extreme."
I exited chat, threw phone aside.
David looked at me.
"Are you okay?"
"Pretty good." I said. "Do you know, when I was little, the saddest thing wasn't having no new dress."
"What was it?"
"It was every time I asked why, Mom always said: You calculate too much, insensible."
"Seemed like my fault. Seemed I shouldn't ask. Seemed I should be like Sister, turn a blind eye to all unfairness, smilingly say Mom you are right."
"But I couldn't do it."
David held my hand tight.
"You don't need to do it." He said. "You asked right."
I leaned on his shoulder, eyes a bit hot.
Phone rang again.
Family group.
Brother sent a voice message.
I clicked, his voice:
"Sis, Mom said, before end of this month, you transfer $380k. Or don't come back for New Year."